Four Ways to Build Engagement in an Inclusive Classroom

Four Ways to Build Engagement in an Inclusive Classroom

Jason Sharpe By Jason Sharpe • October 27, 2026

Are We Asking the Right Questions About Classroom Engagement?

Imagine two pupils sitting in the same classroom, listening to the same teacher and completing the same activity. One begins working almost immediately. The other struggles to get started, becomes distracted and eventually disengages. It would be easy to conclude that the second pupil lacks motivation, concentration or willingness to learn. Depending on their history, we might describe them as reluctant, disruptive or unable to work independently. But what if the difficulty lies somewhere else?

What if the lesson has been designed around a particular way of learning that works well for one pupil but creates unnecessary barriers for another? This question has become increasingly important to me through my work supporting young people with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) and through my Master's studies in Education. We frequently talk about improving pupil engagement, particularly among children with autism, ADHD, dyslexia, speech and language needs or school-related anxiety. Yet we sometimes treat engagement as primarily a characteristic of the child.

A more inclusive approach requires us to examine the relationship between the learner, the task, the teaching and the environment. One research paper that has particularly influenced my thinking is New Approaches to Literacy Problems: Multiliteracies and Inclusive Pedagogies by Drewry, Cumming-Potvin and Maor (2019).

Their research challenges narrow assumptions about literacy and explores how recognising pupils' existing abilities, experiences and interests can create more meaningful opportunities for learning. Drawing on that research, I want to explore four interconnected approaches that teachers can use to support engagement: situated practice, scaffolding, critical understanding and collaboration. These are not four quick fixes for SEND. They are ways of thinking about teaching that can benefit entire classrooms.

What Does the Research Tell Us About Inclusive Teaching?

Drewry and her colleagues explored how a multiliteracies approach could support pupils who experienced difficulties with traditional, print-based classroom activities. Multiliteracies is a broader understanding of literacy that recognises how people communicate and construct meaning through different forms, including written language, images, sound, movement and digital media.

This matters because schools do not always recognise the skills children demonstrate outside school. A child might struggle to produce an extended written response but demonstrate sophisticated communication skills through creating videos, designing digital content, discussing a favourite subject or interpreting visual information.

If classroom success is measured mainly through one form of communication, those abilities may go unnoticed. The researchers examined the experiences of a Year 6 pupil, pseudonym Hannah, whose engagement with creative and digital activities at home contrasted with her difficulties in school-based literacy tasks. The study explored how digital media activities, including iMovies and audiobooks, could connect her interests and abilities to classroom learning. The findings suggest that more flexible approaches to literacy can create participation opportunities that traditional activities may overlook. Importantly, this was a qualitative case study, not proof that any single teaching strategy will work for every learner. Nevertheless, it raises a question that every educator should consider:

Are we recognising what children can already do, or are we concentrating so heavily on what they find difficult that we overlook their strengths?

The original multiliteracies framework includes four components: Situated Practice, Overt Instruction, Critical Framing and Transformed Practice. For this article, I draw on that framework and the wider themes in Drewry and colleagues' research to outline four practical principles for inclusive classroom engagement.

1. Situated Practice: Making Learning Meaningful

Situated practice begins with a straightforward idea: learning becomes more meaningful when it connects with experiences, interests and knowledge that pupils already possess. Rather than assuming that every learner arrives with the same background or starting point, teachers recognise that children bring different experiences into the classroom.

For pupils with SEND, these connections can be particularly valuable. Consider a pupil with ADHD who struggles to engage with a conventional written task about persuasive language. That same pupil might spend hours analysing football commentary, discussing video games, or explaining why one product is better than another. The underlying skills may already be developing. The challenge is helping the pupil recognise how those skills connect with the curriculum. A teacher could introduce persuasive writing through an advertisement for a familiar product, a debate about a school rule, or a game review. The academic objective remains unchanged, but the route into the learning becomes more accessible.

Similarly, a pupil who enjoys creating digital artwork might explore storytelling through a combination of images, spoken narration and written captions before progressing towards a longer written composition. This is not about allowing children to avoid challenging work. It is about establishing meaningful connections that make that work more approachable.

Why Situated Practice Matters for SEND

Some pupils experience additional barriers when classroom tasks feel abstract, unfamiliar or disconnected from their lives. Autistic learners, for example, may benefit from clear explanations of a task's purpose and opportunities to connect new information with established interests. Pupils experiencing anxiety may find familiar contexts less intimidating than entirely unfamiliar activities.

However, we should be careful not to turn these observations into assumptions about every child with a particular diagnosis. The starting point must always be the individual learner. For teachers, situated practice means asking what pupils already understand, what interests them, and how their experiences might support new learning. It also means recognising that valuable learning takes place beyond school. The knowledge a child develops through hobbies, family relationships, community activities and digital experiences can all contribute to their classroom learning.

Practical classroom reflection: Before introducing a new topic, consider whether pupils can connect it to something they already know, understand, or care about.

2. Scaffolding: Providing Support Without Removing Challenge

Scaffolding is a familiar concept in education, yet its importance to inclusive teaching cannot be overstated. At its simplest, scaffolding involves providing appropriate support so that a learner can complete a task they might not yet manage independently. Teachers can then adjust the support as their understanding and confidence develop. This is particularly relevant when working with pupils who experience difficulties with executive functioning, working memory, processing information or organising their thoughts. Imagine asking a class to write an extended response analysing a character's motivations in a novel.

For some pupils, the instruction is sufficient. They can organise their ideas, recall relevant evidence and begin writing. For others, the task may involve several simultaneous demands. They must understand the question, retrieve information, decide what is relevant, organise a response, remember appropriate vocabulary and translate their ideas into written language. A pupil who struggles with this process may understand the character perfectly well but find the demands of producing the answer overwhelming. Without appropriate support, the teacher might interpret the absence of written work as a lack of understanding. Scaffolding helps us distinguish between those possibilities.

What Does Effective Scaffolding Look Like?

Support might involve modelling an example, breaking the task into manageable stages, providing visual prompts, discussing ideas before writing or using a structured writing frame. For a pupil with dyslexia, text-to-speech software or opportunities to record initial ideas orally might reduce barriers related to decoding or transcription. For a pupil with ADHD, a clearly sequenced task and visible checklist may help them stay on track. For an autistic pupil, an explicit explanation of expectations may remove ambiguity that would otherwise make the task difficult. Select these approaches based on individual needs rather than diagnosis alone.

Crucially, scaffolding does not mean lowering expectations. Reducing the intellectual challenge of a task is different from removing an unnecessary barrier to accessing that challenge. A pupil who needs a writing frame may still be capable of sophisticated literary analysis. A pupil who uses speech-to-text software may still be developing complex arguments. We should not confuse a learner's support needs with the limits of their potential.

Knowing When to Adjust Support

Effective scaffolding also requires careful observation. If you withdraw support before a pupil is ready, they may become overwhelmed. If it remains unchanged when they no longer need it, it may restrict independence. The aim is responsive teaching. Sometimes independence means completing a task without assistance. At other times, it means recognising which tools or adjustments help someone work successfully. For pupils with enduring disabilities, some accommodations may remain necessary throughout education and adulthood.

Practical classroom reflection: When a pupil cannot complete a task, ask whether the difficulty concerns the knowledge being assessed or the process required to demonstrate that knowledge. That distinction can transform how we respond.

3. Critical Understanding: Questioning What We Consider Successful Learning

Of the four principles, critical understanding may be the most challenging because it asks educators to examine their own assumptions. We often assess engagement through behaviours that are easy to observe. A pupil sits quietly, looks towards the teacher, completes written work, and follows instructions. We interpret these behaviours as evidence of successful engagement. But are they always reliable indicators?

An autistic pupil may be listening carefully while avoiding eye contact. A pupil with ADHD may concentrate more effectively while moving or using a discreet fidget tool. An anxious pupil may appear compliant while understanding very little because they are focused on managing distress. Equally, a quiet pupil may be disengaged, while a pupil who asks frequent questions may be demonstrating considerable intellectual curiosity. The problem arises when we mistake a preferred classroom behaviour for learning itself.

Who Defines the Ideal Learner?

Critical understanding encourages us to consider how we construct classroom expectations. Why do we associate stillness with attention? Why might a handwritten response be valued more highly than an equally thoughtful spoken explanation? Why do we sometimes interpret a request for clarification as a lack of independence? These questions do not mean that classroom routines, written communication or behavioural expectations are unimportant. They mean that teachers should be able to explain the educational purpose behind those expectations.

For example, handwriting may be the specific skill being taught or assessed. In that situation, written production is central to the learning objective. However, if the objective is to evaluate a pupil's understanding of a historical event, insisting on a lengthy handwritten response may introduce a barrier unrelated to the knowledge being assessed. The distinction matters.

Moving Beyond Deficit-Based Thinking

SEND discussions can sometimes focus on what a pupil cannot do. They cannot sit still. They cannot complete the worksheet. They cannot tolerate the classroom. They cannot work independently. While identifying genuine difficulties is essential, an exclusively deficit-focused approach can narrow our understanding of the learner.

Critical understanding asks us to consider the interaction between the pupil and their environment. If a child becomes distressed whenever a classroom becomes noisy, is the most useful response always to teach them to tolerate the noise? Or should we also examine whether the noise is necessary, whether quieter working arrangements are possible and whether the environment could be adjusted? Sometimes both individual support and environmental changes will be appropriate. The important point is that the responsibility for inclusion should not rest entirely with the child.

Practical classroom reflection: Think about a pupil you have described as disengaged. What evidence supports that judgement, and could another explanation account for their behaviour?

4. Collaboration: Recognising Learning as a Shared Process

Learning is not simply an individual activity taking place inside a child's mind. It is also social. We develop understanding through discussion, observation, shared experiences and interactions with others. Drewry and colleagues' research highlights the value of support from teachers and peers, including opportunities to develop understanding through shared activities. This has important implications for inclusive classrooms. A pupil who struggles to organise ideas independently may produce a more developed response after discussing the topic with a partner. Another pupil may understand a mathematical concept more clearly after explaining their reasoning to someone else.

Collaborative learning can provide opportunities to practise communication, develop confidence and encounter different perspectives. However, collaboration is not automatically inclusive just because pupils are placed in groups.

When Group Work Becomes a Barrier

For some children, poorly structured group activities create significant challenges. An autistic pupil may struggle to navigate unpredictable social expectations. A child experiencing anxiety may fear being judged by peers. A pupil with speech and language needs may struggle to contribute when conversations move quickly. Other pupils may dominate discussions, leaving quieter classmates with little opportunity to participate. If collaboration is to support inclusion, it needs to be carefully designed.

Teachers can make group activities more accessible by establishing clear roles, explaining expectations, providing preparation time and offering different ways to contribute. Some pupils may benefit from working with a familiar partner before participating in a larger group. Others may prefer to prepare their ideas in writing before sharing them. The objective is meaningful participation, not compulsory social interaction for its own sake.

Collaboration Beyond the Classroom

Collaboration also extends to relationships among teachers, families, teaching assistants, SENCOs, and other professionals. Parents often have valuable insight into how their children communicate, manage difficulties, and demonstrate strengths outside school. A pupil who rarely speaks in lessons may be highly articulate at home when discussing a favourite subject. Another who appears settled throughout the school day may experience considerable distress afterwards. Neither perspective provides the complete picture on its own. When educators and families share observations, they can develop a more informed understanding of the child's needs.

The same principle applies to pupil voice. Children should have meaningful opportunities to explain which adjustments help them, what they find difficult and how they experience classroom activities. Of course, not every pupil will communicate this through a conventional conversation. Some may require visual choices, written responses, supported communication or time to reflect.

Practical classroom reflection: When planning collaborative activities, ask whether every pupil has a genuine opportunity to contribute and whether the activity is structured to support different communication needs.

What Might These Four Principles Look Like in One Lesson?

Consider a Year 8 English lesson in which pupils are exploring how writers create tension. A conventional approach might involve reading an extract, answering comprehension questions and writing an analytical paragraph. There is nothing inherently wrong with this structure. For many pupils, it may work well. However, a teacher applying the four principles could make several adjustments without abandoning the learning objective.

  • Situated practice might involve introducing tension through a familiar film scene, audiobook extract or short piece of music. Pupils could discuss how anticipation is created before identifying similar techniques in written language.
  • Scaffolding could involve modelling how to identify a quotation, explain its effect and organise an analytical response. Pupils might use vocabulary prompts or a writing frame, depending on their needs.
  • Critical understanding would encourage the teacher to distinguish between pupils who do not understand the literary techniques and those who understand them but struggle to express their ideas through extended writing.
  • Collaboration might involve structured partner discussions with clear roles and opportunities to prepare responses before sharing.

The learning objective remains ambitious. The difference is that pupils have more than one route into the learning and appropriate support to demonstrate their understanding. Importantly, these adjustments need not be reserved exclusively for pupils with identified SEND. They can be part of ordinary classroom teaching, benefiting pupils whose needs may not yet be recognised.

Does Inclusive Teaching Mean Creating a Different Lesson for Every Child?

One concern teachers frequently express is that inclusive teaching sounds ideal in theory but difficult to deliver in practice. With large classes, curriculum pressures, limited resources, and increasing numbers of pupils needing additional support, how can teachers realistically meet these different needs? This is a legitimate question.

Inclusive teaching cannot depend entirely on individual teachers working longer hours or producing separate lessons for every pupil. Instead, the four principles encourage us to build flexibility into the original design of learning. For example, offering pupils a choice between reading and listening to an introductory text may benefit several learners without requiring multiple lesson plans. Modelling a complex task before independent work can support the whole class. Using visual instructions alongside verbal explanations can improve clarity for pupils with a range of needs.

Similarly, allowing structured discussion before writing may help pupils develop their ideas without compromising academic expectations. These approaches will not eliminate the need for individualised provision. Some pupils require specialist teaching, specific adjustments or support identified through an Education, Health and Care Plan. Inclusive classroom strategies should not become an excuse for failing to provide those resources.

However, thoughtful lesson design can reduce some barriers before they emerge. The goal is not to make every lesson effortless. Learning should involve challenge, curiosity and opportunities to develop resilience. The goal is to ensure the challenge comes from the learning itself, not from unnecessary obstacles in how it is presented.

Why Engagement Matters Beyond Academic Achievement

When we discuss classroom engagement, we often focus on attainment, progress and assessment outcomes. These matter, but engagement also shapes how children see themselves as learners. Imagine repeatedly entering a classroom where you struggle to begin tasks, cannot demonstrate what you know, and receive frequent reminders about what you haven't completed. Over time, those experiences may affect confidence, motivation and a sense of belonging.

For some pupils, disengagement may respond to repeated frustration rather than a lack of interest in education. This is particularly relevant when supporting children experiencing emotionally based school avoidance (EBSA). Although school avoidance has multiple causes and classroom teaching alone cannot explain it, repeated experiences of difficulty or exclusion may shape a pupil's relationship with education.

A more accessible classroom cannot resolve every difficulty, but it can help reduce some of the pressures that make participation harder. This is why I believe engagement is more than securing compliance or increasing the quantity of completed work. It is also about helping pupils experience themselves as capable, valued participants in learning.

Four Questions Every Teacher Can Ask

The principles explored in this article can be brought together through four simple questions:

  1. Situated practice: How does this learning connect with what my pupils already know, experience or value?
  2. Scaffolding: What support will help pupils access the challenge without unnecessarily reducing expectations?
  3. Critical understanding: Am I assessing the intended learning, or am I allowing unrelated barriers to influence my judgement?
  4. Collaboration: Does every pupil have a meaningful and accessible opportunity to participate?

These questions will not provide an instant solution to every challenge teachers face. They can, however, encourage more reflective decisions about curriculum design, classroom expectations and the support we provide.

Conclusion: Perhaps We Need to Rethink Engagement

One of the most important lessons I continue to take from studying inclusive education is that we must be willing to question familiar practices. When a pupil struggles to engage, our instinct is often to focus on changing their behaviour, improving their motivation or increasing their ability to cope. Sometimes those areas genuinely require support. But they should not be the only questions we ask.

We should also examine whether the learning is meaningful, whether appropriate support is available, whether our expectations create unnecessary barriers, and whether pupils have genuine opportunities to participate. Drewry and colleagues' research reminds us that children may possess abilities and interests that conventional classroom activities do not always reveal. Recognising those strengths does not mean abandoning academic standards. It means considering how more pupils can access them.

For teachers, this requires reflection, flexibility and a willingness to challenge assumptions. For pupils with SEND, it can mean the difference between repeatedly experiencing education as something they struggle to access and beginning to recognise themselves as successful learners. And for schools, it raises a wider question about what meaningful inclusion actually looks like.

Perhaps the starting point isn't asking why a child won't engage with our teaching, but how our teaching can better enable that child to engage.


About the Author

Jason Sharpe is an Education & Inclusion Specialist, educator and founder of Mr Gillman Tuition. Through his consultancy work, he supports families, educators and organisations in understanding SEND, school-related anxiety, inclusive practice and alternative educational pathways.

Jason is currently undertaking a Master's in Education, exploring equity, inclusion and the relationship between educational policy and classroom practice.

Through his Parent Pathways initiative and Beyond Behaviour talks, he aims to make complex educational issues more accessible to families and professionals.

For information about education consultancy, professional training and speaking engagements, visit jasonsharpe.co.uk 

Research Reference

Drewry, R. J., Cumming-Potvin, W. M., & Maor, D. (2019). New approaches to literacy problems: Multiliteracies and inclusive pedagogies. Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 44(11), 61–78. https://doi.org/10.14221/ajte.2019v44.n11.4